登陆注册
18902400000020

第20章 Christmas and the Aesthetes(1)

The world is round, so round that the schools of optimism and pessimism have been arguing from the beginning whether it is the right way up.

The difficulty does not arise so much from the mere fact that good and evil are mingled in roughly equal proportions; it arises chiefly from the fact that men always differ about what parts are good and what evil.

Hence the difficulty which besets "undenominational religions."They profess to include what is beautiful in all creeds, but they appear to many to have collected all that is dull in them.

All the colours mixed together in purity ought to make a perfect white.

Mixed together on any human paint-box, they make a thing like mud, and a thing very like many new religions. Such a blend is often something much worse than any one creed taken separately, even the creed of the Thugs.

The error arises from the difficulty of detecting what is really the good part and what is really the bad part of any given religion.

And this pathos falls rather heavily on those persons who have the misfortune to think of some religion or other, that the parts commonly counted good are bad, and the parts commonly counted bad are good.

It is tragic to admire and honestly admire a human group, but to admire it in a photographic negative. It is difficult to congratulate all their whites on being black and all their blacks on their whiteness.

This will often happen to us in connection with human religions.

Take two institutions which bear witness to the religious energy of the nineteenth century. Take the Salvation Army and the philosophy of Auguste Comte.

The usual verdict of educated people on the Salvation Army is expressed in some such words as these: "I have no doubt they do a great deal of good, but they do it in a vulgar and profane style;their aims are excellent, but their methods are wrong."To me, unfortunately, the precise reverse of this appears to be the truth. I do not know whether the aims of the Salvation Army are excellent, but I am quite sure their methods are admirable.

Their methods are the methods of all intense and hearty religions;they are popular like all religion, military like all religion, public and sensational like all religion. They are not reverent any more than Roman Catholics are reverent, for reverence in the sad and delicate meaning of the term reverence is a thing only possible to infidels.

That beautiful twilight you will find in Euripides, in Renan, in Matthew Arnold; but in men who believe you will not find it--you will find only laughter and war. A man cannot pay that kind of reverence to truth solid as marble; they can only be reverent towards a beautiful lie. And the Salvation Army, though their voice has broken out in a mean environment and an ugly shape, are really the old voice of glad and angry faith, hot as the riots of Dionysus, wild as the gargoyles of Catholicism, not to be mistaken for a philosophy.

Professor Huxley, in one of his clever phrases, called the Salvation Army "corybantic Christianity." Huxley was the last and noblest of those Stoics who have never understood the Cross. If he had understood Christianity he would have known that there never has been, and never can be, any Christianity that is not corybantic.

And there is this difference between the matter of aims and the matter of methods, that to judge of the aims of a thing like the Salvation Army is very difficult, to judge of their ritual and atmosphere very easy. No one, perhaps, but a sociologist can see whether General Booth's housing scheme is right.

But any healthy person can see that banging brass cymbals together must be right. A page of statistics, a plan of model dwellings, anything which is rational, is always difficult for the lay mind.

But the thing which is irrational any one can understand.

That is why religion came so early into the world and spread so far, while science came so late into the world and has not spread at all.

History unanimously attests the fact that it is only mysticism which stands the smallest chance of being understanded of the people.

Common sense has to be kept as an esoteric secret in the dark temple of culture. And so while the philanthropy of the Salvationists and its genuineness may be a reasonable matter for the discussion of the doctors, there can be no doubt about the genuineness of their brass bands, for a brass band is purely spiritual, and seeks only to quicken the internal life. The object of philanthropy is to do good;the object of religion is to be good, if only for a moment, amid a crash of brass.

And the same antithesis exists about another modern religion--I mean the religion of Comte, generally known as Positivism, or the worship of humanity. Such men as Mr. Frederic Harrison, that brilliant and chivalrous philosopher, who still, by his mere personality, speaks for the creed, would tell us that he offers us the philosophy of Comte, but not all Comte's fantastic proposals for pontiffs and ceremonials, the new calendar, the new holidays and saints' days.

He does not mean that we should dress ourselves up as priests of humanity or let off fireworks because it is Milton's birthday.

To the solid English Comtist all this appears, he confesses, to be a little absurd. To me it appears the only sensible part of Comtism.

As a philosophy it is unsatisfactory. It is evidently impossible to worship humanity, just as it is impossible to worship the Savile Club;both are excellent institutions to which we may happen to belong.

But we perceive clearly that the Savile Club did not make the stars and does not fill the universe. And it is surely unreasonable to attack the doctrine of the Trinity as a piece of bewildering mysticism, and then to ask men to worship a being who is ninety million persons in one God, neither confounding the persons nor dividing the substance.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 曾经恓惶谁许我一世地老天荒

    曾经恓惶谁许我一世地老天荒

    在爱情世界里,我一无所有,也一无所知。你要伴我宠我,永远。-即墨雪衣放弃了,后悔了。-金珉硕只想让你知道我爱你,我在想你!-鹿晗我选择爱或更爱你,你选择爱或不爱我。-吴亦凡这是我第一次不唠叨的告诉你一件事,你要听好了:我喜欢你。-金俊勉喜欢你,却错过了。-张艺兴看我的眼睛,你会发现你对我而言意味着什么。-边伯贤看到你的眼神那一瞬,我已被你吸引!-金钟大你可以不理我但不可以不理解我。-朴灿烈我像喜欢吃的一样喜欢你。-都暻秀你身上的伤,要是我弄的就要入骨,要是别人,哪怕半点我也心疼。-黄子韬我为什么一看到你就发烧呢?-金钟仁把我送给你,不许忽视外借丢弃。-吴世勋
  • 仙侠道途

    仙侠道途

    【起点三组签约,完本保证】这是一个正魔相争的世界。在这里,有中原、东海、西漠、北荒和南疆五地,其中,中原为人类聚集最多之地,由正道领袖藏龙门镇守。在这里,有修道者,便是那些一心求道,求长生,求永生之人,修炼天赐法诀,便可延长寿命,并且获得强大的实力,其中强大着,可借助天地之力,翻山倒海,引雷布雨亦可为之!本书,便是讲的一个数千年之前被从上天引来的一具神龙尸体与一个藏龙门弟子的故事!这里,有人性的转变,有大道的感悟,有爱恨情仇,有热血激斗!人生三世,魔僧魔,此为仙侠道途!【新人新书,求收藏,求推荐票,求一切能求的!!粉丝群:194250925】
  • 犯上冷情王爷

    犯上冷情王爷

    他,当朝冥王,残暴冷情,王妃于他而言摆设罢了。既然皇帝赐婚,他就卖个面子又如何,娶她权当冥王府多养一个废人。可这废柴女人居然大婚之日众目睽睽之下撒开脚丫子落跑?女人,有些胆色,他会陪她好好玩玩!
  • 吃药小窍门

    吃药小窍门

    日常生活中,食疗吃药小窍门。如:治感冒发烧:生嚼大蒜治感冒:可把鲜蒜瓣含于口中,生嚼不咽下,直至大蒜无辣味时吐掉。连续用3瓣大蒜即可见效。一般用于感冒初起、鼻流清涕、风寒咳嗽等病症。
  • EXO之有你们真好

    EXO之有你们真好

    不要离开我,我怕你受伤害。——xiumin我是你哥哥,我有资格保护你。——灿烈你做的饭好好吃,能天天都吃到吗?——鹿晗不想
  • 惊撼世界的100场战争(上)

    惊撼世界的100场战争(上)

    本书对世界历史的真实过程做了纵深的透视,对人类文明的伟大成就做了全面的阐述,它从浩瀚的历史文库中,撷取精华、汇聚经典、分门别类地对历史上曾经发生的重大事件进行分析介绍,向广大读者尤其是青年朋友们打开了一扇历史的窗口,让他们穿越时空隧道,在历史的天空中遨游、于探幽寻秘中启迪智慧,启发思考,启示未来。
  • 沉沦的荣耀

    沉沦的荣耀

    夏小瑶来到了一个她从来没有到过的世界,所有的事物都是新奇而美好。她又是领主与真神都想利用的工具。领主之战一触即发,其中利益交错复杂,谁能成为红古大陆的最新秩序?是真神,领主,还是妖灵。是谁在操纵着这一切,所有的家族都在捍卫自己的家族荣耀,而家族荣耀的背后却必须放弃自身的荣耀,什么才是这个世界最重要的。爱情,生存,权利,人各有志。
  • 修仙接班人

    修仙接班人

    这一天,是江小飞飞升的日子。从他穿着背心大短裤,踩着人字拖降临昆仑界的那一刻起。昆仑界开始出现了一个自称修仙接班人的绝世天才。各位道友,咱动口不动手!有话好好说!
  • 丑妻诱人爱

    丑妻诱人爱

    骨架大嗓门粗,皮肤黑嘴唇厚,雷若尔是上流圈中赫赫有名的花痴丑女,痴爱姐夫——冷傲潇洒的黄金总裁莫潇皓,被说成癞蛤蟆想吃天鹅肉。想不到,姐姐婚礼前晚私会男人出车祸,为两家面子着想,她被迫披上婚纱,也开始了地狱般的折磨。新婚之夜砸破她的头,找牛郎轻薄她,回门之日,她满脸青紫,惨不忍睹,威胁挖苦,冷嘲热讽后,他得意讥笑,你还是控制不了自己爱我。幸亏善良细腻的艺术家小叔子一次次帮她度过难关,却不敢正视这份爱情,只是默默守护。雷若尔一步步接近想要的幸福。。。。。。
  • 你的销售错在哪儿

    你的销售错在哪儿

    本书从日常销售工作出发,汇集了销售人员经常遇到的、可能会犯的错误,通过案例进行描述,并对案例进行评析,后面还附有成功销售人员的精彩案例,并就具体的实施方法作了具体的分析,每章的最后都作了总结,对于销售人员的具体操作有着明确的指导。