登陆注册
18902400000020

第20章 Christmas and the Aesthetes(1)

The world is round, so round that the schools of optimism and pessimism have been arguing from the beginning whether it is the right way up.

The difficulty does not arise so much from the mere fact that good and evil are mingled in roughly equal proportions; it arises chiefly from the fact that men always differ about what parts are good and what evil.

Hence the difficulty which besets "undenominational religions."They profess to include what is beautiful in all creeds, but they appear to many to have collected all that is dull in them.

All the colours mixed together in purity ought to make a perfect white.

Mixed together on any human paint-box, they make a thing like mud, and a thing very like many new religions. Such a blend is often something much worse than any one creed taken separately, even the creed of the Thugs.

The error arises from the difficulty of detecting what is really the good part and what is really the bad part of any given religion.

And this pathos falls rather heavily on those persons who have the misfortune to think of some religion or other, that the parts commonly counted good are bad, and the parts commonly counted bad are good.

It is tragic to admire and honestly admire a human group, but to admire it in a photographic negative. It is difficult to congratulate all their whites on being black and all their blacks on their whiteness.

This will often happen to us in connection with human religions.

Take two institutions which bear witness to the religious energy of the nineteenth century. Take the Salvation Army and the philosophy of Auguste Comte.

The usual verdict of educated people on the Salvation Army is expressed in some such words as these: "I have no doubt they do a great deal of good, but they do it in a vulgar and profane style;their aims are excellent, but their methods are wrong."To me, unfortunately, the precise reverse of this appears to be the truth. I do not know whether the aims of the Salvation Army are excellent, but I am quite sure their methods are admirable.

Their methods are the methods of all intense and hearty religions;they are popular like all religion, military like all religion, public and sensational like all religion. They are not reverent any more than Roman Catholics are reverent, for reverence in the sad and delicate meaning of the term reverence is a thing only possible to infidels.

That beautiful twilight you will find in Euripides, in Renan, in Matthew Arnold; but in men who believe you will not find it--you will find only laughter and war. A man cannot pay that kind of reverence to truth solid as marble; they can only be reverent towards a beautiful lie. And the Salvation Army, though their voice has broken out in a mean environment and an ugly shape, are really the old voice of glad and angry faith, hot as the riots of Dionysus, wild as the gargoyles of Catholicism, not to be mistaken for a philosophy.

Professor Huxley, in one of his clever phrases, called the Salvation Army "corybantic Christianity." Huxley was the last and noblest of those Stoics who have never understood the Cross. If he had understood Christianity he would have known that there never has been, and never can be, any Christianity that is not corybantic.

And there is this difference between the matter of aims and the matter of methods, that to judge of the aims of a thing like the Salvation Army is very difficult, to judge of their ritual and atmosphere very easy. No one, perhaps, but a sociologist can see whether General Booth's housing scheme is right.

But any healthy person can see that banging brass cymbals together must be right. A page of statistics, a plan of model dwellings, anything which is rational, is always difficult for the lay mind.

But the thing which is irrational any one can understand.

That is why religion came so early into the world and spread so far, while science came so late into the world and has not spread at all.

History unanimously attests the fact that it is only mysticism which stands the smallest chance of being understanded of the people.

Common sense has to be kept as an esoteric secret in the dark temple of culture. And so while the philanthropy of the Salvationists and its genuineness may be a reasonable matter for the discussion of the doctors, there can be no doubt about the genuineness of their brass bands, for a brass band is purely spiritual, and seeks only to quicken the internal life. The object of philanthropy is to do good;the object of religion is to be good, if only for a moment, amid a crash of brass.

And the same antithesis exists about another modern religion--I mean the religion of Comte, generally known as Positivism, or the worship of humanity. Such men as Mr. Frederic Harrison, that brilliant and chivalrous philosopher, who still, by his mere personality, speaks for the creed, would tell us that he offers us the philosophy of Comte, but not all Comte's fantastic proposals for pontiffs and ceremonials, the new calendar, the new holidays and saints' days.

He does not mean that we should dress ourselves up as priests of humanity or let off fireworks because it is Milton's birthday.

To the solid English Comtist all this appears, he confesses, to be a little absurd. To me it appears the only sensible part of Comtism.

As a philosophy it is unsatisfactory. It is evidently impossible to worship humanity, just as it is impossible to worship the Savile Club;both are excellent institutions to which we may happen to belong.

But we perceive clearly that the Savile Club did not make the stars and does not fill the universe. And it is surely unreasonable to attack the doctrine of the Trinity as a piece of bewildering mysticism, and then to ask men to worship a being who is ninety million persons in one God, neither confounding the persons nor dividing the substance.

同类推荐
  • 東三省輿地圖說

    東三省輿地圖說

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 润州二首

    润州二首

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 折狱龟鉴

    折狱龟鉴

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Dead Souls

    Dead Souls

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 活地狱

    活地狱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 百鬼众魅

    百鬼众魅

    爷爷是个老摄影迷,喜欢给我拍照,却从来都不给我看,直到爷爷去世那天,我看到了这些让我惊诧的照片……我试图寻找真相,梦魇接踵而来,一件件事情让我猝不及防……
  • 点亮智慧人生全集(白金版)

    点亮智慧人生全集(白金版)

    人生路上正在迷茫的人,读了此书,会看到曙光;生活困顿的人看了此书,会看到力量;深陷痛苦的人,看了此书,会找到幸福的方向;活在爱中的人,看了此书,会懂得感恩;蹉跎生命的人,看了此书,会懂得珍惜;徘徊在人生岔路口的人,读了此书,会找到信仰。
  • 斩神

    斩神

    素衣清雅的过路妹子、才貌双全的一代名妓、风华绝代的大姐姐!在这个强者为尊,英雄遍地的时代,且看穿越来的霸道兵王如何带着他的乖乖宠物——圣兽白虎,问鼎巅峰,掀起惊天狂澜,又是如何万花丛中独领风骚,引得群芳只为他而艳……
  • 大威怒乌刍涩摩仪轨

    大威怒乌刍涩摩仪轨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 冲出牢笼

    冲出牢笼

    第一卷讲的是一个说漏嘴的少年一对从小分开的姐妹(谜之音:此处有坑)一对相互敌视的兄妹一个以身证道的青年高手一个骑着猪的长鞭青年之间的故事你所预料到的结局,未必是真正的结局。
  • 主播娇妻

    主播娇妻

    三年前,她是他的未婚妻,却在婚礼当日成为落跑新娘。三年后,再次相见,她成了当红主播,他成了让人捉摸不透的冷血BOSS。两个人意外发生了关系,并全国直播,从此两个人再次纠葛在了一起。为了利益,他与她成为协议情人,而她却无法看透他的内心。“你对我到底是真,还是演戏?”“论起演戏,你比我的演技更高!”
  • 目经大成

    目经大成

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 甜蜜的负荷:跟你去边疆

    甜蜜的负荷:跟你去边疆

    为了阻止父亲的第二次婚姻,陆宛宁撒娇耍泼酗酒离家出走都干过了,却未能达到目的。更郁闷的是半路还杀出个酷爱多管闲事的林东兴,本以为以后要称呼他表哥,没想到在一次次口舌之争中失落了心。陆宛宁说过她不是任何人的责任,可是林东兴只想对她好。有什么办法,真心已经交付,他遇见她的脆弱、彷徨和无助,她是他甜蜜的负荷。...害怕你突然再不出现在我的生命里我意识到除了死别,还有生离不管哪一样发生在你身上只要我想到就特别难过...所以,现在我愿意跟你去边疆
  • 逆炼成仙

    逆炼成仙

    山村少年机缘巧合之下进入修真界,没有逆天的资质,有的只有一腔热血……且看他如何凭借一枚古怪的戒指纵横仙途,立足与修真界!
  • 泪不单行

    泪不单行

    司羽、丸子和予桐是从小一起长大的好朋友,三个人之间一直有着些许的暧昧。高三开学之后班上转来一个南方来的姑娘安柔,司羽在朋友们的帮助下和安柔走到了一起。本来两个人约好考同一所大学,可是高考之后安柔不辞而别,司羽只能独自去往曾经两个人一起幻想的地方读书。在大学用了很长时间决定从头开始新的生活,经过又一次感情上的波折之后,突然发现有了好感的女孩竟然和安柔有着莫大的关系。再一次和安柔旧事重提,司羽该何去何从……