登陆注册
18902400000047

第47章 On Smart Novelists and the Smart Set(1)

In one sense, at any rate, it is more valuable to read bad literature than good literature. Good literature may tell us the mind of one man; but bad literature may tell us the mind of many men.

A good novel tells us the truth about its hero; but a bad novel tells us the truth about its author. It does much more than that, it tells us the truth about its readers; and, oddly enough, it tells us this all the more the more cynical and immoral be the motive of its manufacture. The more dishonest a book is as a book the more honest it is as a public document.

A sincere novel exhibits the simplicity of one particular man;an insincere novel exhibits the simplicity of mankind.

The pedantic decisions and definable readjustments of man may be found in scrolls and statute books and scriptures;but men's basic assumptions and everlasting energies are to be found in penny dreadfuls and halfpenny novelettes. Thus a man, like many men of real culture in our day, might learn from good literature nothing except the power to appreciate good literature.

But from bad literature he might learn to govern empires and look over the map of mankind.

There is one rather interesting example of this state of things in which the weaker literature is really the stronger and the stronger the weaker. It is the case of what may be called, for the sake of an approximate description, the literature of aristocracy;or, if you prefer the description, the literature of snobbishness.

Now if any one wishes to find a really effective and comprehensible and permanent case for aristocracy well and sincerely stated, let him read, not the modern philosophical conservatives, not even Nietzsche, let him read the Bow Bells Novelettes.

Of the case of Nietzsche I am confessedly more doubtful.

Nietzsche and the Bow Bells Novelettes have both obviously the same fundamental character; they both worship the tall man with curling moustaches and herculean bodily power, and they both worship him in a manner which is somewhat feminine and hysterical.

Even here, however, the Novelette easily maintains its philosophical superiority, because it does attribute to the strong man those virtues which do commonly belong to him, such virtues as laziness and kindliness and a rather reckless benevolence, and a great dislike of hurting the weak. Nietzsche, on the other hand, attributes to the strong man that scorn against weakness which only exists among invalids. It is not, however, of the secondary merits of the great German philosopher, but of the primary merits of the Bow Bells Novelettes, that it is my present affair to speak.

The picture of aristocracy in the popular sentimental novelette seems to me very satisfactory as a permanent political and philosophical guide.

It may be inaccurate about details such as the title by which a baronet is addressed or the width of a mountain chasm which a baronet can conveniently leap, but it is not a bad description of the general idea and intention of aristocracy as they exist in human affairs.

The essential dream of aristocracy is magnificence and valour;and if the Family Herald Supplement sometimes distorts or exaggerates these things, at least, it does not fall short in them.

It never errs by making the mountain chasm too narrow or the title of the baronet insufficiently impressive. But above this sane reliable old literature of snobbishness there has arisen in our time another kind of literature of snobbishness which, with its much higher pretensions, seems to me worthy of very much less respect. Incidentally (if that matters), it is much better literature. But it is immeasurably worse philosophy, immeasurably worse ethics and politics, immeasurably worse vital rendering of aristocracy and humanity as they really are.

From such books as those of which I wish now to speak we can discover what a clever man can do with the idea of aristocracy.

But from the Family Herald Supplement literature we can learn what the idea of aristocracy can do with a man who is not clever.

And when we know that we know English history.

This new aristocratic fiction must have caught the attention of everybody who has read the best fiction for the last fifteen years.

It is that genuine or alleged literature of the Smart Set which represents that set as distinguished, not only by smart dresses, but by smart sayings. To the bad baronet, to the good baronet, to the romantic and misunderstood baronet who is supposed to be a bad baronet, but is a good baronet, this school has added a conception undreamed of in the former years--the conception of an amusing baronet.

The aristocrat is not merely to be taller than mortal men and stronger and handsomer, he is also to be more witty.

He is the long man with the short epigram. Many eminent, and deservedly eminent, modern novelists must accept some responsibility for having supported this worst form of snobbishness--an intellectual snobbishness. The talented author of "Dodo" is responsible for having in some sense created the fashion as a fashion.

Mr. Hichens, in the "Green Carnation," reaffirmed the strange idea that young noblemen talk well; though his case had some vague biographical foundation, and in consequence an excuse. Mrs. Craigie is considerably guilty in the matter, although, or rather because, she has combined the aristocratic note with a note of some moral and even religious sincerity. When you are saving a man's soul, even in a novel, it is indecent to mention that he is a gentleman.

Nor can blame in this matter be altogether removed from a man of much greater ability, and a man who has proved his possession of the highest of human instinct, the romantic instinct--I mean Mr. Anthony Hope.

In a galloping, impossible melodrama like "The Prisoner of Zenda,"the blood of kings fanned an excellent fantastic thread or theme.

But the blood of kings is not a thing that can be taken seriously.

同类推荐
  • 中风论

    中风论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 紫柏尊者别集

    紫柏尊者别集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 剧话

    剧话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • The Patchwork Girl of Oz

    The Patchwork Girl of Oz

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛顶最胜陀罗尼经

    佛顶最胜陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 赢得人脉的社交诀窍:点旺人气的七大交际智慧

    赢得人脉的社交诀窍:点旺人气的七大交际智慧

    现代社会中,网络的普及更为人们的沟通开辟了全新的空间,创造了全新的天地。社会中的生活交往,商务交往,友情交往,借用各种现代化的手段,已变得日益快捷、便利和时尚。但不要忘了,人是有思想、有感情的动物,在人际交往中,任何时候、任何东西都无法替代人的智慧与人的情感。以一种高尚的人格做人,以一种独特的魅力社交,丰富的人脉就自然掌握在你的手中。
  • A Man of Business

    A Man of Business

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 第十四次见面

    第十四次见面

    今晚他睡不着,因为明天他又要去见一个网友。“甜甜猪”,女,22岁,属羊。他对于她就只知道这么多,就连她的名字他也不知道。他睡不着,因为两年间的经历让他紧张。他紧张,因为他怕又一次遭遇恐龙。莫名的恐惧让他失眠。有风,风冷。人民公园西南角,桂花树下,长凳上。林键看着树上落的七七八八的树叶和地上的枯草。他突然想笑,十三次的经历,十三次的落荒而逃。今天他可能又要重复一次。他嘴角挂着微笑,他不怕,因为他对生活充满信心,对未来充满信心。约定见面是他提出来的,地点和条件是她指定的。看了看手表,他比约定的时间早了十五分钟。她还没有来。一阵风吹过,本来不多的枯叶又飘下不少。
  • 张东荪传

    张东荪传

    五四风云人物书系《张东荪传》,一个在历史拐弯处被甩掉的名字,一个被遗忘半个世纪的风云人物,1930年之前五十年间,输入西方哲学方面最广、影响最大。
  • 魂归辽叶河

    魂归辽叶河

    《魂归辽叶河》是重庆作家张地国为时5年创作的长篇小说,由北京燕山出版社出版发行。小说讲述的是上个世纪知识青年上山下乡,到农村插队落户的故事,故事从上世纪70年代初讲到二十一世纪初,时间跨度30年,人物众多、情节曲折。人物形象丰满,真实可信,无论是知青还是当地村民,他们都有着独特的个性特征。与众多知青影视文学作品不同的是,《魂归辽叶河》不仅写了知青一代在农村的生活经历,还讲述了知青在改革开放的春风中,到城市的创业历程,以及知青的子女们的成长经历,他们延续着父辈精神,在逆境中拚搏进取,实现人生价值。
  • 阴阳猎命

    阴阳猎命

    心中有座坟,葬着我的尸。我从没有想过自己为什么要当一个阴阳师,或许是想从道士、和尚、方术士三者折中选一。或者是得过且过,习惯了为不学无术找合适的理由。又或者是,冥冥中命运早已做出了这么一份安排。我已经顾不得太多,也无法回头,在相对于日常的生活中抽丝剥茧,方才可以在无数令人颤抖的诡异猎奇事件中活下去。如果你有心,请你静静在午夜翻开,且听我说说我的故事。
  • 三国有个公孙恭

    三国有个公孙恭

    公孙恭穿越三国,成为辽东太守戏览天下英豪。逐乌桓,灭北平,扫袁绍,公孙恭渐成三国时代的河北霸主,但前面,还有曹刘孙三方枭雄!‘这天下!非我公孙恭莫属!’‘我要让这三国时代,成为公孙恭的时代!’总结:这是一本很爽的三国争霸文。
  • 剑斩仙途

    剑斩仙途

    仙缘为零?修仙难?成仙难?雨樱花表示无碍,气运逆天的挚友在手,机缘滚滚来!只是滚过头了而已...某落败世家,师尊美如画,师姐是学霸,小师妹才是掌家!心诚,意坚,自有人助她青云直上!就是过程无(坑)奈(爹)了点。多年后,脱胎换骨的她静倚西风,一剑在手,天下我大可走!(ps:新书求推荐求收藏~完本在手,坑品我有!)
  • 再过一个冬天

    再过一个冬天

    或许再过几个冬天,世界就会完全不一样,或许再过几年,你我都会变化,因为我们在成长……
  • 无良神医

    无良神医

    三流医科大学毕业的唐睿明,学的是西医,对西医却一窍不通。在一个偶然的机会他得到了一本中医秘籍,从此开始了他的多彩人生……