登陆注册
19098000000014

第14章 (6)

It is important to emphasize the point that what determines value is not the time taken to produce a thing, but the minimum time it could possibly be produced in, and the minimum is ascertained by competition. Suppose for a moment that there is no more competition and consequently no longer any means to ascertain the minimum of labor necessary for the production of a commodity; what will happen? It will suffice to spend six hours' on the production of an object, in order to have the right, according to M.

Proudhon, to demand in exchange six times as much as the one who has taken only one hour to produce the same object.

Instead of a "proportional relation", we have a disproportional relation, at any rate if we insist on sticking to relations, good or bad.

The continual depreciation of labor is only one side, one consequence of the evaluation of commodities by labor time. The excessive raising of prices, overproduction and many other features of industrial anarchy have their explanation in this mode of evaluation.

But does labor time used as a measure of value give rise at least to the proportional variety of products that so delights M. Proudhon?

On the contrary, monopoly in all its monotony follows in its wake and invades the world of products, just as to everybody's knowledge monopoly invades the world of the instruments of production. It is only in a few branches of industry, like the cotton industry, that very rapid progress can be made. The natural consequence of this process is that the products of cotton manufacture, for instance, fall rapidly in price: but as the price of cotton goes down, the price of flax will be replaced by cotton.

In this way, flax has been driven out of almost the whole of North America.

And we have obtained, instead of the proportional variety of products, the dominance of cotton.

What is left of this "proportional relation"? Nothing but the pious wish of an honest man who would like commodities to be produced in proportions which would permit of their being sold at an honest price.

In all ages good-natured bourgeois and philanthropic economists have taken pleasure in expressing this innocent wish.

Let us hear what old Boisguillebert says:

"The price of commodities," he says, "must always be proportionate;for it is such mutual understanding alone that can enable them to exist together so as to give themselves to one another at any moment (here is M. Proudhon's continual exchangeability) and reciprocally give birth to one another....

"As wealth, then, is nothing but this continual intercourse between man and man, craft and craft, etc., it is a frightful blindness to go looking for the cause of misery elsewhere than in the cessation of such traffic brought about by a disturbance of proportion in prices."( Dissertation sur la nature des richesses , Daire's ed. [pp.405 and 408])[Boisguillebert's work is quoted from the symposium Economistes-financiers du XVIII siecle . Prefaced by a historical sketch on each author and accompanied by commentaries and explanatory notes by Eugene Daire;Paris 1843.]

Let us listen also to a modern economist:

"The great law as necessary to be affixed to production, that is, the law of proportion, which alone can preserve the continuity of value....

"The equivalent must be guaranteed....

"All nations have attempted, at various periods of their history, by instituting numerous commercial regulations and restrictions, to effect, in some degree, the object here explained....

But the natural and inherent selfishness of man... has urged him to break down all such regulations. Proportionate Production is the realization of the entire truth of the Science of Social Economy."(W. Atkinson, Principles of Political Economy , London 1840, pp.170-95)Fuit Troja . [Troy is no more.] This true proportion between supply and demand, which is beginning once more to be the object of so many wishes, ceased long ago to exist. It has passed into the stage of senility. It was possible only at a time when the means of production were limited, when the movement of exchange took place within very restricted bounds.

With the birth of large-scale industry this true proportion had to come to an end, and production is inevitably compelled to pass in continuous succession through vicissitudes of prosperity, depression, crisis, stagnation, renewed prosperity, and so on.

Those who, like Sismondi, wish to return to the true proportion of production, while preserving the present basis of society, are reactionary, since, to be consistent, they must also wish to bring back all the other conditions of industry of former times.

What kept production in true, or more or less true, proportions?

It was demand that dominated supply, that preceded it. Production followed close on the heels of consumption. Large-scale industry, forced by the very instruments at its disposal to produce on an ever-increasing scale, can no longer wait for demand. Production precedes consumption, supply compels demands.

In existing society, in industry based on individual exchange, anarchy of production, which is the source of so much misery, is at the same time the source of all progress.

Thus, one or the other:

Either you want the true proportions of past centuries with present-day means of production, in which case you are both reactionary and utopian.

Or you want progress without anarchy: in which case, in order to preserve the productive forces, you must abandon individual exchange.

Individual exchange is suited only to the small-scale industry of past centuries with its corollary of "true proportion", or else to large-scale industry with all its train of misery and anarchy.

同类推荐
  • 医闾漫记

    医闾漫记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Murat

    Murat

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 九天应元雷声普化天尊玉枢宝忏

    九天应元雷声普化天尊玉枢宝忏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 壬归

    壬归

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 小儿肛胀门

    小儿肛胀门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 生命最后的读书会

    生命最后的读书会

    在得知母亲胰腺癌晚期后,威尔一直不知道该如何面对这件事并自然地跟母亲沟通。偶然的一天,他们开始阅读同样的书,为了在母亲之后的化疗中两人可以一起探讨这本书。两个人的读书会就这么开始了。在固定进行的读书会期间,他们开始了一段阅读广度和人生深度的对话之旅。从热门惊悚小说到经典畅销书,从诗歌到悬疑故事,从异想天开到精神层次探讨……穿插着作者对儿时的回忆、母亲的不平凡经历、各自的人生际遇,借阅读,他们探讨了勇气、信仰、孤独,感恩、学习倾听甚至葬礼等多个话题,分享着各自对文字和生命的态度和观点。最终,他们可以真诚地交换彼此对死亡的观点了。
  • 寞桃花开自倾华

    寞桃花开自倾华

    陶夭是个不谙世事的姑娘,单纯,热情,引人向往。冉邵熙是华王朝的战神,冷漠,无情,令人恐惧。首次见她,一袭粉衣,三千青丝绕人心肠,眉眼弯弯歪头看他。俏丽若三春之桃,清素若九秋之菊。脑海里在看到她时便蹦出这句诗。她给指明道路,他不负圣望又一次立下战功。"我叫陶夭,陶瓷的陶,夭折的夭。""夭夭,我定不负你一生年华。""夭夭,我从不管你是谁,只要是你我便认定了……""夭夭,夭夭,我的夭夭……"
  • 凌天战神

    凌天战神

    重生?穿越?这些词为何那么有既视感。好巧不巧的,我遇到了,希望这不是第一次,也不是最后一次。
  • 不是这一种爱你

    不是这一种爱你

    “是不是我去死,你才会高兴?”他的语气变得低迷起来。望着他有些受伤的神情,安琉的身体哆嗦了一下,想要张口说些什么,可却找不到任何可以回驳的话,不是?这不是我希望的?其实有那么一瞬间,安琉是真的那么想过。她咬了咬自己的嘴唇,最终还是沉默了下来。凌陌指了指她的心口,“你这里,从来就没有我的位置,就算只是他,也比我重要千倍万倍。”安琉呆愣的望着他,看着他眉眼间的疼痛仿佛感同身受一般,自己的心也跟着抽痛着。“安琉你记住,这个世上不会再有人会为了你这么糟践自己,因为是你亲手捏碎了他的心。”冰天雪地的寒冷占据了他乌黑的眼眸,凌陌将她推向了墙面,身后就抵着冰冷的瓷砖,安琉难忍的挣扎。--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 倾城浮华:天女万岁万万岁

    倾城浮华:天女万岁万万岁

    身为天女的继承后代,竟然在继承大典上消失得无影无踪,而原本被指为未婚夫的他,竟然就是现今皇上,这可白让我们的陌卿占了个大便宜啊,不过事愿人违,皇后竟已有人选,这让我们的女主大为不快,只好带上我们天女的头衔,在这后宫中翻云覆雨了。你们,接招吧!
  • 天命贵女

    天命贵女

    一朝穿越,一世不凡。她前世本是一名杀手,如今却成了相府傻子嫡女。是命运还是算计?他,只是个笨蛋。傻子,笨蛋?惊天计划?不对,还有......
  • 易烊千玺之你会爱我吗

    易烊千玺之你会爱我吗

    当千年冰山易烊千玺遇到萌萌哒的女主,会发生什么呢?
  • 盖世武尊

    盖世武尊

    寻道路上,人若阻我,一拳碎之!神若阻我,一脚踏之!天若欺我,一戟破之!道若阻我,那便一碑封之!你狂吾更狂,看谁称尊而道皇!
  • 共识:中国在改革中前行

    共识:中国在改革中前行

    中国的社会经济以至人们的思想观念在过去十年的时间中都发生了深刻的变化。中国迅速崛起却也危机四伏。中国实现了什么样的梦想,又陷入了哪些困境,当再次走在新的十字路口,改革共识弱化或破裂的声音不断出现,我们又会选择什么样的前进道路,这些问题,都在本书中有着犀利的点评与剖析。 当前,中国改革的难度越来越大,经济改革走向更深层次,也会遭遇更多错综复杂的利益博弈;本来已经滞后的政治改革,既要避开多重障碍的清算,又需要高超的智慧;民生的呼声也越来越高;等等。在中国发展的关键时刻,达成深入改革的共识的重要性与必要性毋庸质疑。本书以共识为主题,契合了当前的社会需求与政治需求。
  • 痛苦是一颗珍珠(保持学生良好心态的故事全集)

    痛苦是一颗珍珠(保持学生良好心态的故事全集)

    走进如歌的生命,走过诗意的青春。曾几何时,我们叹息时光的飞逝,叹惋落日的凄美,却任凭美好从身边转瞬即逝。不是青春短暂、岁月苍白,而是我们不曾将它涂上丰富的色彩。何不于喧闹中体会宁静,于繁杂中感受简约,以平静的心情看待得失,以良好的心态面对功利,“不以物喜,不以己悲”才是人生之大境界。