登陆注册
19098000000033

第33章 (6)

Just the as antithesis was before turned into an antidote, so now the thesis becomes a hypothesis. This change of terms, coming from M. Proudhon, has no longer anything surprising for us! Human reason, which is anything but pure, having only incomplete vision, encounters at every step new problems to be solved. Every new thesis which it discovers in absolute reason and which is the negation of the first thesis, becomes for it a synthesis, which it accepts rather naively as the solution of the problem in question.

It is thus that this reason frets and fumes in ever renewing contradictions until, coming to the end of the contradictions, it perceives that all its theses and syntheses are merely contradictory hypotheses. In its perplexity, "human reason, social genius, returns in one leap to all its former positions, and in a single formula, solves all its problems". This unique formula, by the way, constitutes M. Proudhon's true discovery. It is constituted value.

Hypotheses are made only in view of a certain aiM. The aim that social genius, speaking through the mouth of M. Proudhon, set itself in the first place, was to eliminate the bad in every economic category, in order to have nothing left but the good. For it, the good, the supreme well-being, the real practical aim, is equality. And why did the social genius aim at equality rather than inequality, fraternity, catholicism, or any other principle? Because "humanity has successively realized so many separate hypotheses only in view of a superior hypothesis", which precisely is equality. In other words: because equality is M. Proudhon's ideal. He imagines that the division of labor, credit, the workshop --all economic relations -- were invented merely for the benefit of equality, and yet they always ended up by turning against it. Since history and the fiction of M. Proudhon contradict each other at every step, the latter concludes that there is a contradiction. If there is a contradiction, it exists only between his fixed idea and real movement.

Henceforth, the good side of an economic relation is that which affirms equality; the bad side, that which negates it and affirms inequality.

Every new category is a hypothesis of the social genius to eliminate the inequality engendered by the preceding hypothesis. In short, equality is th e primordial intention, the mystical tendency, the providential aim that the social genius has constantly before its eyes as it whirls in the circle of economic contradictions. Thus, Providence is the locomotive which makes the whole of M. Proudhon's economic baggage move better than his pure and volatized reason. He has devoted to Providence a whole chapter, which follows the one on taxes.

Providence, providential aim, this is the great word used today to explain the movement of history. In fact, this word explains nothing.

It is at most a rhetorical form, one of the various ways of paraphrasing facts.

It is a fact that in Scotland landed property acquired a new value by the development of English industry. This industry opened up new outlets for wool. In order to produce wool on a large scale, arable land had to be transformed into pasturage. To effect this transformation, the estates had to be concentrated. To concentrate the estates, small holdings had first to be abolished, thousands of tenants had to be driven from their native soil and a few shepherds in charge of millions of sheep to be installed in their place. Thus, by successive transformations, landed property in Scotland has resulted in the driving out of men by sheep. Now say that the providential aim of the institution of landed property in Scotland was to have men driven out by sheep, and you will have made providential history.

Of course, the tendency towards equality belongs to our century.

To say now that all former centuries, with entirely different needs, means of production, etc., worked providentially for the realization of equality is, firstly, to substitute the means and the men of our century for the men and the means of earlier centuries and to misunderstand the historical movement by which the successive generations transformed the results acquired by the generations that preceded theM. Economists know very well that the very thing that was for the one a finished product was for the other but the raw material for new production.

Suppose, as M. Proudhon does, that social genius produced, or rather improvised, the feudal lords with the providential aim of transforming the settlers into responsible and equally-placed workers: and you will have effected a substitution of aims and of persons worthy of the Providence that instituted landed property in Scotland, in order to give itself the malicious pleasure of driving out men by sheep.

But since M. Proudhon takes such a tender interest in Providence, we refer him to the Histoire de l'economie politique of M. de Villeneuve-Bargemont, who likewise goes in pursuit of a providential aiM. This aim, however, is not equality, but catholicism.

Seventh and Last Observation Economists have a singular method of procedure. There are only two kinds of institutions for them, artificial and natural. The institutions of feudalism are artificial institutions, those of the bourgeoisie are natural institutions.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 扬鞭战国时代

    扬鞭战国时代

    老天开了个玩笑,竟然被穿越了!更过分的是,穿越也就算了,竟然穿到了日本战国时代!堂堂华夏男儿穿越到了世敌之地,不做点什么岂不是对不起华夏这份血脉?从此,混乱的战国时代变得更加混乱了……“马鹿野郎!我要求武士待遇!”“我呸你一脸,只要你跳起来够得到门框,就给你武士待遇!”……
  • 小儿初生护养门

    小儿初生护养门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 纵横神魔

    纵横神魔

    山无棱,天地合,才敢与君绝,看一段惊心动魄的故事。
  • 神之试验地

    神之试验地

    你可曾想过,在那无边无尽的宇宙中,有这么一群人,为了生存的星系而游走在死亡的边缘。你可幻想过,在那万千世界中留下只属于你的传奇故事。修真,斗气,魔法,未来世界,看来自地球都市的林鹏如何化身为魔,只为了心中最后的执念。“只有染满鲜血,我才能托起那颗蔚蓝色的星球。”
  • 冉冉森起

    冉冉森起

    两个姐妹的故事。。。大家想知道她们之间会发生什么吗,看下去。。。。。。。。。。。。。。
  • 一世盛宠:甜宠皇后成长记

    一世盛宠:甜宠皇后成长记

    别人穿越都是虎躯一震四方来拜,我穿越是孤女一个四方来嘲。别人穿越都是青梅竹马两小无猜,我穿越是大叔养成强制霸道。穿越大神~~~~我给你刷了那么多Yooooo~,你就这么对我吗????
  • 吸血别恋

    吸血别恋

    吸血鬼登场?一边呆着去吧!当今可是半吸血鬼的天下!男人也绝美?这有什么稀奇,禁忌之爱产生的混血儿魅力谁人能挡?颠覆了传统印象,走入半吸血鬼的情感世界,揭开冰漠面具下的丝丝柔情!
  • 冷妻归来,boss小心宠

    冷妻归来,boss小心宠

    她杀人如麻,冷若冰霜,却不小心在水下“强吻”了他,他目瞪口呆,那一夜辗转反侧。她被打伤,他枪指那人,“世上敢伤她的人,全都得死!”她被男人追,他狠话撂下,“谁敢追她,活腻味了?”她抱怨,“你烦不烦?我吃饭你管,睡觉你管,现在连杀个人你也要管?”他绅士微笑故装不懂,“老婆说什么?今晚七次,好啊!”
  • 提升修养的118种现代礼仪

    提升修养的118种现代礼仪

    爱默生说:“美好的行为比美好的外表更有力量;美好的行为比形象和外貌更能带给人快乐。这是一种精美的人生艺术。”“以礼服人”、“礼多人不怪”,这是古老的中国格言,它在今天仍有十分实用的效果。随着社会的进步,人类文明的发展,人们的社会交往日益频繁。礼仪作为联系沟通交往的桥梁,显得更为重要。随着国际交往的日益频繁,东西方文化之间产生了密切的交流与激烈的碰撞,这就促使了世界各地的礼仪与习俗不断地融合与发展。因此,我们就要了解符合时代精神的礼仪知识,良好的礼仪教养本身就是财富。举止优雅的人离开了金钱也能够成功,秘密就在于他们拥有世界各地最受欢迎的“通行证”—礼。
  • 裂缝爱恋

    裂缝爱恋

    假如能够换取你新生,错乱时空又何妨你的死去,带来的是某人对你的思念,你的重生,带来的是某人的欣喜。你的离世,有人愿意用时空的错乱为代价来换得你重生,这样的人,你值得爱恋和拥有,你应该真心待他。小说以男主人公刘彦宁的时空穿越为线索,讲述了刘科技彦宁与寇静甜的爱情故事。故事中,刘彦宁在一次偷盗过程中意外穿越到未来世界,且穿越后时光机器莫名损坏,接着他便遇到了寇静甜,不过寇静甜却在一次事故中意外死亡,而刘彦宁为救活寇静甜则使用当时的科技多次进行时空穿越……