登陆注册
19098000000036

第36章 (1)

DIVISION OF LABOR AND MACHINERY

T he division of labor, according to M. Proudhon, opens the series of economic evolutions.

"Considered in its essence, the | division of labor is the manner | in which equality of conditions | and intelligence is realized."

Good side of the |(Vol.I, p.93)division of labor

"The division of labor has | become for us an instrument of | poverty."

(Vol.I, p.94)

Variant

"Labor, by dividing itself | according to the law which is | peculiar to it, and which is the Bad side of the | primary conditions of its fruit-division of labor| fulness, ends in the negation of | its aims and destroys itself."

(Vol.I, p.94)

To find the "recomposition Problem to be solved | which wipes out the drawbacks | of the division, while retaining | its useful effects."

(Vol.I, p.97) The division of labor is, according to M. Proudhon, an eternal law, a simple, abstract category. Therefore the abstraction, the idea, the word must suffice for him to explain the division of labor at different historical epochs.

Castes, corporations, manufacture, large-scale industry, must be explained by the single word divide . First study carefully the meaning of "divide", and you will have no need to study the numerous influences which give the division of labor a defintive character in every epoch.

Certainly, things would be made much too easy if they were reduced to M. Proudhon's categories. History does not proceed so categorically.

It took three whole centuries in Germany to establish the first big division of labor, the separation of the towns from the country. In proportion, as this one relation of town and country was modified, the whole of society was modified. To take only this one aspect of the division of labor, you have the old republics, and you have Christian feudalism; you have old England with its barons and you have modern England with its cotton lords.

In the 14th and 15th centuries, when there were as yet no colonies, when America did not yet exist for Europe, when Asia existed only through the intermediary of Constantinople, when the Mediterranean was the centre of commercial activity, the division of labor had a very different form, a very different aspect from that of the 17th century, when t he Spanish, the Portuguese, the Dutch, the English, and the French had colonies established in all parts of the world. The extent of the market, its physiognomy, give to the division of labor at different periods a physiognomy, a character, which it would be difficult to deduce from the single word divide , from the idea, from the category.

"All economists since Adam Smith," says M. Proudhon, "have pointed out the advantages and drawbacks of the law of div- ision, but insist much more on the first than on the second, because that was more serviceable for their optimism, and none of them has ever wondered what could be the drawbacks to a law.... How does the same principle, pursued vigor- ously to its consequences, lead to diametrically opposite results? Not one economist before or since A. Smith has even perceived that here was a problem to elucidate. Say goes to the length of recognizing that in the division of labor the same cause that produces the good engenders the bad."[I 95-96]

Adam Smith goes further than M. Proudhon thinks. He saw clearly that "the difference of natural talents in different men is, in reality, much less than we are aware of; and the very dif- ferent genius which appears to distinguish men of different professions, when grown up to maturity, is not so much the cause as the effect of the division of labor."[I 20]

In principle, a porter differs less from a philosopher than a mastiff from a greyhound. It is the division of labor which has set a gulf between theM.

All this does not prevent M. Proudhon from saying elsewhere that Adam Smith has not the slightest idea of the drawbacks produced by the division of labor. it is this again that makes him say that J. B. Say was the first to recognize "that in the division of labor the same cause that produces the good engenders the bad." [I 96]

But let us listen to Lemontey; Suum cuique .[34]

"M. J. B. Say has done me the honor of adopting in his excellent treatise on political economy the principle that I brought to light in this fragment on the moral influence of the division of labor. The somewhat frivolous title of my book [35] doubtless prevented him from citing me. It is only to this motive that I can attribute the silence of a writer too rich in his own stock to disavow so modest a load."(Lemontey, OEuvres completes , Vol.I, p.245, Paris 1840)Let us do him this justice: Lemontey wittily exposed the unpleasant consequences of the division of labor as it is constituted today, and M. Proudhon found nothing to add to it. But now that, through the fault of M. Proudhon, we have been drawn into this question of priority, let us say again, in passing, that long before M. Lemontey, and 17 years before Adam Smith, who was a pupil of A. Ferguson, the last-named gave a clear exposition of the subject in a chapter which deals specifically with the division of labor.

"It may even be doubted, whether the measure of national capacity increases with the advancement of arts. Many mech- anical arts... succeed best under a total suppression of sentiment and reason; and ignorance is the mother of indus- try as well as superstition. Reflection and fancy are sub- ject to err; but a habit of moving the hand, or the foot, is independent of either. Manufactures, accordingly, prosper most, where the mind is least consulted, and where the work- shop may, without any great effort of imagination, be considered as an engine, the parts of which are men....

"The general officer may be a great proficient in the knowledge of war, while the skill of the soldier is confined to a few motions of the hand and the foot. The former may have gained what the latter has lost....

同类推荐
  • 平金川

    平金川

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说妇人遇辜经

    佛说妇人遇辜经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 阎典史传

    阎典史传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 上清经真丹秘诀

    上清经真丹秘诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 医宗己任编

    医宗己任编

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 幽灵代言人

    幽灵代言人

    身在异乡的异能姑娘姬小小在一件一件的怪事中慢慢找到了自己的位置,幽灵代言人是他给她的外号,没想到却成为两个人的未来以及永远……
  • 仗剑上九重

    仗剑上九重

    人族、神族、魔族并存的世界,唯有自身强大,才能主宰自己的命运,庇护亲人、族人。一个母亲陷入沉睡、父亲失踪的少年,一步步强大,寻父救母......
  • 韩娱:真的很爱很爱你

    韩娱:真的很爱很爱你

    她最开始是S.M.公司的练习生,学校的顽皮国中女孩,现在她是F(X)的忙内,她是郑秀晶。他最开始是S.M.公司的练习生,学校里的校草,现在的他是EXO的忙内,他是吴世勋。他最开始出道前在街头演出,高中生里的面瘫,现在的他是infinite的门面担当,他是金明洙。然而,他们都喜欢上了郑秀晶,而小小年纪的郑秀晶渐生情愫。。她最终会选择谁?真的很爱很爱你——郑秀晶
  • 落难嫡女误入非人庵

    落难嫡女误入非人庵

    辰天六月十八夜,鹤城窦家血光冲天。窦家独女窦蓝护着高烧的幼弟,前脚刚被人从藏身地窖中挖了出来,后脚便被一干叔伯族亲囫囵送去了严宁庵。严宁庵,是个横绝古今远近闻名的……疯人庵。破旧的马车咔吱一声停了下来。窦蓝颤颤巍巍抱着虚弱的幼弟,在心里默念了一百遍家仇血誓,毅然走下车去。入眼的,是长满苔藓的古旧石梯,阴森的青石排门,一脸刻板的管家姑子,和,她身后不太安分的大红尾巴。对于一个刚经历了家毁人亡的、正处于塑造三观的关键阶段的少女而言,比疯人庵更糟糕的地方是什么?
  • 创业实战

    创业实战

    本书紧密围绕创业过程中的关键问题编写,包括:激发创业头脑、提升创业能力、确定创业战略、掌握创业管理、运用创业模式、创业模拟训练、实施创业实战等,内容丰富,知识性强,具有以下三个特点:第一,结构简练,条理清晰;第二,深入浅出,通俗易懂;第三,实战性强,便于操作。既可作为全国高等院校管理类本科生以及非管理类学生的创业管理教材,也可作为企业创业培训的教材,还可作为社会各方研究者、创业者的自学参考书。
  • 世界最具可读性的短篇小说(4)

    世界最具可读性的短篇小说(4)

    我的课外第一本书——震撼心灵阅读之旅经典文库,《阅读文库》编委会编。通过各种形式的故事和语言,讲述我们在成长中需要的知识。
  • 婚不由己之娇妻诱人

    婚不由己之娇妻诱人

    曾经她是方家恶女。十八岁更是仗着财势棒打鸳鸯,硬把小竹马逼进了洞房里!谁想好景不长,因为伤人她“哐当”一声进了监狱。抛弃大小姐的身份,她沦为下仆,离婚吧。可却被总裁卓然拒绝,在前有腹黑继兄,后有小鲜肉守门,他开始了他艰辛的追妻之路!本文纯属虚构,请勿模仿。
  • 骗婚:惹上极品CEO

    骗婚:惹上极品CEO

    (文文已大结局!)黑耀爵,他是商业帝国里的王,鬼斧神工般雕刻的五官,阴邪的气息犹如地狱的王者一般,让人只消一眼便臣服与他怖人的气势之下。花解语,她是道上赫赫有名的神偷,只要是她想要的东西,从来就没有失手过。但是面对着那个王者般的男子时,却一而再再而三的失手了。一个是腹黑的总裁,一个是绝色的神偷,因为一条项链而命运紧紧的纠缠在一起的两人,究竟是谁先失了心?又是谁先爱上了谁?
  • 鸡肋

    鸡肋

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 灵圃仙君

    灵圃仙君

    一花一世界,途殊而道归,仙路始灵宵,终成神仙君!