登陆注册
19646300000043

第43章 4

So much, then, for the first stage of our problem. The next step is to raise the question whether syllogism-i.e. demonstration-of the definable nature is possible or, as our recent argument assumed, impossible.

We might argue it impossible on the following grounds:-(a) syllogism proves an attribute of a subject through the middle term; on the other hand (b) its definable nature is both 'peculiar' to a subject and predicated of it as belonging to its essence. But in that case (1) the subject, its definition, and the middle term connecting them must be reciprocally predicable of one another; for if A is to C, obviously A is 'peculiar' to B and B to C-in fact all three terms are 'peculiar' to one another: and further (2) if A inheres in the essence of all B and B is predicated universally of all C as belonging to C's essence, A also must be predicated of C as belonging to its essence.

If one does not take this relation as thus duplicated-if, that is, A is predicated as being of the essence of B, but B is not of the essence of the subjects of which it is predicated-A will not necessarily be predicated of C as belonging to its essence. So both premisses will predicate essence, and consequently B also will be predicated of C as its essence. Since, therefore, both premisses do predicate essence-i.e. definable form-C's definable form will appear in the middle term before the conclusion is drawn.

We may generalize by supposing that it is possible to prove the essential nature of man. Let C be man, A man's essential nature--two-footed animal, or aught else it may be. Then, if we are to syllogize, A must be predicated of all B. But this premiss will be mediated by a fresh definition, which consequently will also be the essential nature of man. Therefore the argument assumes what it has to prove, since B too is the essential nature of man. It is, however, the case in which there are only the two premisses-i.e. in which the premisses are primary and immediate-which we ought to investigate, because it best illustrates the point under discussion.

Thus they who prove the essential nature of soul or man or anything else through reciprocating terms beg the question. It would be begging the question, for example, to contend that the soul is that which causes its own life, and that what causes its own life is a self-moving number; for one would have to postulate that the soul is a self-moving number in the sense of being identical with it. For if A is predicable as a mere consequent of B and B of C, A will not on that account be the definable form of C: A will merely be what it was true to say of C. Even if A is predicated of all B inasmuch as B is identical with a species of A, still it will not follow: being an animal is predicated of being a man-since it is true that in all instances to be human is to be animal, just as it is also true that every man is an animal-but not as identical with being man.

We conclude, then, that unless one takes both the premisses as predicating essence, one cannot infer that A is the definable form and essence of C: but if one does so take them, in assuming B one will have assumed, before drawing the conclusion, what the definable form of C is; so that there has been no inference, for one has begged the question.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 凤舞苍穹 冥帝的宠妃

    凤舞苍穹 冥帝的宠妃

    她是国家顶级特工拥有着毁天灭地的强大法力他是世人眼中的冷酷王爷有着少有人知的绝地至尊身份一场背叛两个不同时空的人产生交集命运之神的交换轮回之门的重启宿命的因缘终将开始。。。
  • 伪公主的无奈

    伪公主的无奈

    她原本是一个天真可爱的小女孩,她拥有世上最幸福的家庭,有疼爱她的家人,可是突然有一天,她的父母死了,十年后,她回来复仇了,复仇时,哥哥变成维护她的仇人了,她十年前其中一个好朋友告诉她,她并不是凝冰梦紫,但他的母亲与她的母亲却有很大的关系,她最爱的人因为误会她和她哥哥的原因背叛了她。、、
  • 双生语

    双生语

    “同年同月同日生!”奶生奶气的女娃嘴里总念着。“同食同寝福同享!”另个长的一模一样的女娃,也总接着。—“姐姐!你在哪!”怀中还紧抱着一个大白面馒头,望着空荡荡的破庙,柴堆被踢散,落得满地都是。“呜呜——”小女孩被封住了嘴,绑住了脚,心中想着,妹妹你去哪了,我好怕,救救我。—“你为什么要出现。”坐在床上,眼中凶狠的看着那个熟睡中的人。“你凭什么总是跟我抢,什么都可以分,唯独他不可以!”嘴里嘟囔着,从枕头底下抽出了一把刀。—曾经欢声与共,血脉相连。然而命运却让她们背道相持,两人的心越走越远。“你我,终究不应该是双生,我们本是不同的人。”眼泪无止的掉落,伸出手抚摸了那张相同的脸庞,说不尽的苦涩辛酸。
  • 异灵神

    异灵神

    狼人,吸血鬼,狮身人,狗头阿努比斯,这些都弱爆啦,你知道我是谁么,老子是烛龙!
  • 假如爱上女牙医

    假如爱上女牙医

    17岁的叶芬淋让人感觉十分的亮眼,不是说她长得有多漂亮而是你看到她的第一眼会被她身上的朝气给吸引,渐而移不开眼儿。虽然只是身着一身休闲运动装,还特意带了一顶鸭舌帽却依然阻挡不住众GG扫射过来的目光。不理会周围的目光,拿着自己的滑板车走进了夜莺高校的大门。
  • 苏悉地羯罗经请问品

    苏悉地羯罗经请问品

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 娇弱or霸道:学长剥皮史

    娇弱or霸道:学长剥皮史

    我是个小白,什么都不懂的小白,有父有母,想要向上爬的小白,一直认为就算脸生得好些,也无关大局。谁知摊上个看上去萌萌哒的Boss兼学长,不就是被你强吻了吗?!我都没计较你夺走了我的初吻,你有必要那么大张旗鼓地弄得人人皆知吗?!我真是倒了八辈子血霉,才会来你的大学!某boss:“是吗?早晚你会遇到我的,我可爱的小野猫!”可笑我以前竟然因为你的皮囊认为你身娇体弱易推倒,现在一看,你无非就是一只隐藏在你娇弱皮囊下的霸道总裁!资本家!
  • 新概念作文十六年纪念版精华范本(才女卷)

    新概念作文十六年纪念版精华范本(才女卷)

    近几年中学语文教育也在大幅度改革,许多人认为高考作文的命题和新概念作文大赛复赛题已经相当接近,这是非常好的发展趋势。正如王蒙所说,新概念由旧概念来。倡导新概念不是为了标新立异,而是想提高青年学子对作文的兴趣,告诉他们只有真实的、表达真情实感的、富有创造性和想象力的文章才是好文章。
  • 千军问道

    千军问道

    神秘莫测的星域世界,无与伦比的科幻修真时代,一个被联邦最才华的科学家折磨了十八年的少年欧阳,从这里开始他人生的第一步。神奇的法宝,特别的器灵,震撼宇宙的星际修真,强大无比的机关战偶。这里有科幻,有修真!且看一位少年,如何演绎一场特别的科幻修真传奇。
  • The Land of Little Rain

    The Land of Little Rain

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。