登陆注册
19851600000030

第30章 WORK AND PAY(3)

There is a fundamental difference between Socialism and Anarchism as regards the question of distribution.Socialism, at any rate in most of its forms, would retain payment for work done or for willingness to work, and, except in the case of persons incapacitated by age or infirmity, would make willingness to work a condition of subsistence, or at any rate of subsistence above a certain very low minimum.Anarchism, on the other hand, aims at granting to everyone, without any conditions whatever, just as much of all ordinary commodities as he or she may care to consume, while the rarer com- modities, of which the supply cannot easily be indefinitely increased, would be rationed and divided equally among the population.Thus Anarchism would not impose any OBLIGATIONS of work, though Anarchists believe that the necessary work could be madesufficiently agreeable for the vast majority of the population to undertake it voluntarily.Socialists, on the other hand, would exact work.Some of them would make the incomes of all workers equal, while others would retain higher pay for the work which is considered more valuable.All these different systems are compatible with the common ownership of land and capital, though they differ greatly as regards the kind of society which they would produce.

Socialism with inequality of income would not differ greatly as regards the economic stimulus to work from the society in which we live.Such differences as it would entail would undoubtedly be to the good from our present point of view.Under the existing system many people enjoy idleness and affluence through the mere accident of inheriting land or capital.Many others, through their activities in industry or finance, enjoy an income which is certainly very far in excess of anything to which their social utility entitles them.On the other hand, it often happens that inventors and discoverers, whose work has the very greatest social utility, are robbed of their reward either by capitalists or by the failure of the public to appreciate their work until too late.The better paid work is only open to those who have been able to afford an expensive training, and these men are selected in the main not by merit but by luck.The wage earner is not paid for his willingness to work, but only for his utility to the employer.Consequently, he may be plunged into destitution by causes over which he has no control.Such destitution is a constant fear, and when it occurs it produces undeserved suffering, and often deterioration in the social value of the sufferer.These are a few among the evils of our existing system from the standpoint of production.All these evils we might expect to see remedied under any system of Socialism.

There are two questions which need to be considered when we are discussing how far work requires the economic motive.The first question is: Must society give higher pay for the more skilled or socially more valuable work, if such work is to be done in sufficient quantities? The second question is: Could work be made so attractive that enough of it would be done even if idlers received just as much of the produce of work? The first of these questions concerns the division between two schools ofSocialists: the more moderate Socialists sometimes concede that even under Socialism it would be well to retain unequal pay for different kinds of work, while the more thoroughgoing Socialists advocate equal incomes for all workers.The second question, on the other hand, forms a division between Socialists and Anarchists; the latter would not deprive a man of commodities if he did not work, while the former in general would.

Our second question is so much more fundamental than our first that it must be discussed at once, and in the course of this discussion what needs to be said on our first question will find its place naturally.

Wages or Free Sharing?--``Abolition of the wages system'' is one of the watchwords common to Anarchists and advanced Socialists.But in its most natural sense it is a watchword to which only the Anarchists have a right.In the Anarchist conception of society all the commoner commodities will be available to everyone without stint, in the kind of way in which water is available at present.[41] Advo- cates of this system point out that it applies already to many things which formerly had to be paid for, e.g., roads and bridges.They point out that it might very easily be extended to trams and local trains.They proceed to argue--as Kropotkin does by means of his proofs that the soil might be made indefinitely more productive--that all the commoner kinds of food could be given away to all who demanded them, since it would be easy to produce them in quantities adequate to any possible demand.If this system were extended to all the necessaries of life, everyone's bare livelihood would be secured, quite regardless of the way in which he might choose to spend his time.As for commodities which cannot be produced in indefinite quantities, such as luxuries and delicacies, they also, according to the Anarchists, are to be distributed without payment, but on a system of rations, the amount available being divided equally among the population.No doubt, though this is not said, something like a price will have to be put upon these luxuries, so that a man may be free to choose how he will take his share: one man will prefer good wine, another the finest Havana cigars, another pictures or beautiful furniture.Presumably, every man will be allowed to take such luxuries as are his due in whatever form he prefers, the relative prices being fixed so as to equalize the demand.In such a world as this,the economic stimulus to production will have wholly disappeared, and if work is to continue it must be from other motives.[42]

同类推荐
  • 山国轨

    山国轨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说贝多树下思惟十二因缘经

    佛说贝多树下思惟十二因缘经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 正统临戎录

    正统临戎录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说师子月佛本生经

    佛说师子月佛本生经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • Whirligigs

    Whirligigs

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 生命的密码

    生命的密码

    亘古永恒的时空舞台演绎着如梦如歌的天地玄妙,充满着神奇的千古谜团,而生命本身就是其中之一。热爱生活,珍惜生命,解读身体语言,认知你我他……本书分生命的历程、人体的奥秘、人体趣闻、健康与生活四部分。
  • 用人大师

    用人大师

    宫惠珉先生在《用人大师》一书中系统地研究了很多世界级公司,分析它们如何实施人才战略、如何使用人才,建构公司的竞争优势,确实能为很多企业提供非常宝贵的参考价值。更为难得的是,宫惠珉在《用人大师》一书中结合中国传统文化的用人思想,使读者了解人才的战略性运用并非源于欧美领先企业,而是中国传统文化宝库的一部分。
  • 股经

    股经

    如果你初入股市,还没赚到任何利润——那么,不要急,于用真正的货币进行交易,先采用一种想象的方法。只有通过实践和研究,你才能学会如何交易。不要持续交易低价股票,高价股票快速获利的几率更大。补仓之前,先清理你手头的股票。如果你在股市上一直很“倒霉”,那么你最好先离开一阵,考虑一下是什么原因造成了你的损失。不要用别人的钱进行交易。不要轻信任何看上去似乎“胜券在握”的交易。更深入的细节,尽在《股经》之中。
  • 女仙大人:魔君请上榻

    女仙大人:魔君请上榻

    狗血版简介:简单来说,就是天帝和楠竹打了个赌,身为第一女仙的女主被罚下凡间。五岁大就被强吻,并且定亲。然后你懂得,就不说了。两人爱的你侬我侬后,楠竹身份暴露,遭遇一群反派拆散。最后,结局我肯定不告诉你。(本文完结,有点小虐,请勿黑我,人过留票)【欢迎加群:214087626。敲门砖:角色名,作者名,书名都可以】
  • 活尸美人

    活尸美人

    (这是以前用另一个笔名写的一篇旧文,绝非抄袭或盗文,求围观,本故事纯粹虚构,与正史无关!)晚清末年,纷乱的年代,他们从尸骨中走出来,最后又跌回乱尸堆里;是非成败,谁定功过?有人说他们是袅雄,有人说他们是妖孽;一百多年后,禁锢的界域,被人无意间闯入;尘封的怨念,再次记起;前生,谁欠了谁的,统统都得还来,一场隔世的报复杀戮拉开了序幕。
  • 腹黑王爷小兽妃

    腹黑王爷小兽妃

    作为一只高大上的神龙,龙小墨一直以为自己很酷炫,直到她遇见了段黎........作为段氏王朝最有钱,最有权的的王爷,段黎一直以为他的人生圆满了,直到他遇见了龙小墨.........
  • 轩辕兼帝水经药法

    轩辕兼帝水经药法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 超级农场

    超级农场

    落魄青年林言,偶然得到滴血空间。一切变得不一样了,种植各种极品蔬菜,养殖各类珍奇野兽,与世界餐厅五百强合作,成为学校最大蔬菜供货商。琉璃青菜,水晶黄瓜,腥红番茄,中华鱼子酱,至尊神户牛肉,白金葡萄酒。林言的目标是打造出一个超级农庄。只不过除了作为农庄庄主这个身份外,他还很有许多特殊的身份,比如播音主持人,大学教授,特别行动小组特工,音乐家,演员……除此之外,他还有许多特长,琴棋书画、诗酒花茶,样样精通,会功夫、会雕刻、会收妖,对了,他甚至还会开飞机。
  • 仙缘尘花舛

    仙缘尘花舛

    这是一个妖魔群舞的时代,利用人性的弱点可以把人推向万劫不复。他是一个充满仇恨的没落前朝皇裔,国仇家恨的选择让他不得不痛下决心,斩断儿女情长,坠入魔道,与妖为伍,最终成就了他的南宫八卦阵法,只为逐鹿中原,指日可待。她是一个由仙子变为凡人的幻仙,千回百转,一个柔弱的女子变得强大,隐忍,甚至残酷,挥剑于他,却不知依然柔情似水,只为守护千年的爱恋。当群魔妖怪蠢蠢欲动,试图掌控人间之时,天下之乱,是谁的觉悟,谁的智慧,拯救了苍生?最终的归属又何去何从?
  • 蔓陀萝

    蔓陀萝

    鲍贝:居杭州。中国作协会员,二级作家,浙江省作协签约作家。出版长篇《爱是独自缠绵》,《红莲》,《伤口》;中短篇小说集《撕夜》;随笔集《悦读江南女》,《轻轻一想就碰到了天堂》等。