登陆注册
19880000000004

第4章

Once more, as it is quite certain that the term "fowl" includes the bats,--for in Leviticus xi. 13-19 we read, "And these shall ye have in abomination among the fowls ... the heron after its kind, and the hoopoe, and the bat,"--it is obvious that bats are also said to have been created at stage No. 3. And as bats are mammals, and their existence obviously presupposes that of terrestrial "beasts," it is quite clear that the latter could not have first appeared as No. 5. I need not repeat my reasons for doubting whether man came "last of all."As the latter half of Mr. Gladstone's sixfold order thus shows itself to be wholly unauthorised by, and inconsistent with, the plain language of the Pentateuch, I might decline to discuss the admissibility of its former half.

But I will add one or two remarks on this point also. Does Mr.

Gladstone mean to say that in any of the works he has cited, or indeed anywhere else, he can find scientific warranty for the assertion that there was a period of land--by which I suppose he means dry land (for submerged land must needs be as old as the separate existence of the sea)--"anterior to all life?"It may be so, or it may not be so; but where is the evidence which would justify any one in making a positive assertion on the subject? What competent palaeontologist will affirm, at this present moment, that he knows anything about the period at which life originated, or will assert more than the extreme probability that such origin was a long way antecedent to any traces of life at present known? What physical geologist will affirm that he knows when dry land began to exist, or will say more than that it was probably very much earlier than any extant direct evidence of terrestrial conditions indicates?

I think I know pretty well the answers which the authorities quoted by Mr. Gladstone would give to these questions; but Ileave it to them to give them if they think fit.

If I ventured to speculate on the matter at all, I should say it is by no means certain that sea is older than dry land, inasmuch as a solid terrestrial surface may very well have existed before the earth was cool enough to allow of the existence of fluid water. And, in this case, dry land may have existed before the sea. As to the first appearance of life, the whole argument of analogy, whatever it may be worth in such a case, is in favour of the absence of living beings until long after the hot water seas had constituted themselves; and of the subsequent appearance of aquatic before terrestrial forms of life.

But whether these "protoplasts" would, if we could examine them, be reckoned among the lowest microscopic algae, or fungi; or among those doubtful organisms which lie in the debatable land between animals and plants, is, in my judgment, a question on which a prudent biologist will reserve his opinion.

I think that I have now disposed of those parts of Mr.

Gladstone's defence in which I seem to discover a design to rescue his solemn "plea for revelation." But a great deal of the "Proem to Genesis" remains which I would gladly pass over in silence, were such a course consistent with the respect due to so distinguished a champion of the "reconcilers."I hope that my clients--the people of average opinions--have by this time some confidence in me; for when I tell them that, after all, Mr. Gladstone is of opinion that the "Mosaic record"was meant to give moral, and not scientific, instruction to those for whom it was written, they may be disposed to think that I must be misleading them. But let them listen further to what Mr. Gladstone says in a compendious but not exactly correct statement respecting my opinions:--<quote>

He holds the writer responsible for scientific precision: I look for nothing of the kind, but assign to him a statement general, which admits exceptions; popular, which aims mainly at producing moral impression; summary, which cannot but be open to more or less of criticism of detail. He thinks it is a lecture. I think it is a sermon" (p. 5).

<end quote>

I note, incidentally, that Mr. Gladstone appears to consider that the <i>differentia</i> between a lecture and a sermon is, that the former, so far as it deals with matters of fact, may be taken seriously, as meaning exactly what it says, while a sermon may not. I have quite enough on my hands without taking up the cudgels for the clergy, who will probably find Mr. Gladstone's definition unflattering.

But I am diverging from my proper business, which is to say that I have given no ground for the ascription of these opinions; and that, as a matter of fact, I do not hold them and never have held them. It is Mr. Gladstone, and not I, who will have it that the pentateuchal cosmogony is to be taken as science.

My belief, on the contrary, is, and long has been, that the pentateuchal story of the creation is simply a myth. I suppose it to be an hypothesis respecting the origin of the universe which some ancient thinker found himself able to reconcile with his knowledge, or what he thought was knowledge, of the nature of things, and therefore assumed to be true. As such, I hold it to be not merely an interesting, but a venerable, monument of a stage in the mental progress of mankind; and I find it difficult to suppose that any one who is acquainted with the cosmogonies of other nations--and especially with those of the Egyptians and the Babylonians, with whom the Israelites were in such frequent and intimate communication--should consider it to possess either more, or less, scientific importance than may be allotted to these.

同类推荐
  • 善恶图全传

    善恶图全传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 炮炙全书

    炮炙全书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 荆楚岁时记

    荆楚岁时记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 阳秋剩笔

    阳秋剩笔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说阿弥陀经义疏

    佛说阿弥陀经义疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 重生之都市女仙医

    重生之都市女仙医

    她一手出神入化的针灸可治任何疾病,她一手超凡入圣的符箓可治各种鬼魂,人称女仙医的她,在面对这位俊美如天神、温雅又霸道的男人时候,她只能闻声而逃。难道这个人就是她的克星?“这个混蛋,追了几千年也不嫌累。”“你逃不掉的,乖乖跟我回去成亲。”(本文纯属虚构,请勿模仿。)
  • 青春为何那么伤

    青春为何那么伤

    青春或许就是一个不断受伤的过程。颜可可在平安夜意外发现男朋友劈腿,也因为这样又开始了另外一段恋情。天若有情天亦老,人若有情死得早。颜可可因为在一次意外中,男友为救她身亡。她一直活在深深的愧疚中,但老天似乎跟她没完,一直在用各种方式来报复她。失去庇翼的她又是如何面对的呢?
  • 幻道魔君

    幻道魔君

    看一个铁血少年的复仇之路,一步一步称霸洪魂!
  • 最有效的108条职场守则

    最有效的108条职场守则

    本书精选的职场故事从求职技巧、工作态度、工作方法、职场感悟以及如何晋升等方面为您提供最有效的参考,相信您一定能从中领悟到更多的职场生存智慧。忠诚、敬业、服从与勤奋是身处职场不可或缺的态度,而真正使你成功的是方法、是创意、是应该遵循的潜规则。只有了解职场守则才能减少差错,增加效率,从而养成一种习惯、树立一种行为准则。本书告诉我们成功有章可循!短小精悍的职场故事,像一把智慧的钥匙,开启心门,帮助你打开成就事业的通道。
  • 凡尔纳密码:地心游记

    凡尔纳密码:地心游记

    小说讲述的是德国矿物学教授黎登布洛克带领侄子阿克赛、向导汉恩斯进行的一次惊心动魄的地心探险旅行。他们从冰岛的斯奈弗陷口开始,经历了缺水、迷路、巨兽、暴风雨、高温等种种常人难以想象的困难,经历了千难万险,就在他们将要到达地心时,火山爆发了!在炙热的岩浆推滚下,他们经由意大利西西里岛的火山口回到了地面。全书情节波澜起伏,文章幽默流畅,不仅详细地描绘了探险的起因、种种周密的准备,探险过程中惊险的遭遇,还用浪漫主义的想象手法为我们展示了冰岛风光和地底下的奇特景观,把读者带进了一个超越时空的幻想世界。
  • 绝世嫡仙:腹黑九小姐

    绝世嫡仙:腹黑九小姐

    废物?傻子?这样的词就没有在萧虞汐身上!前世遭队友暗算,如今穿越到异世,依旧是一个传奇!宣王要修了我是吗?正合我意!神兽稀有是吗?谁能告诉她身后这些萌物是什么!炼丹师稀有是吗?只要跟着姐,糖豆随便吃!真元双修稀有是吗?对不起,姐姐我!就!是!美男稀有是吗?我家亲爱哒拉出去,绝对帅瞎你们的眼!看我异世魂魄,如何收服天下!
  • 识小编

    识小编

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 中老年养生保健指南(生活必备丛书)

    中老年养生保健指南(生活必备丛书)

    本书主要从中老年人的生理、运动、医疗、生活、心理、饮食和长寿等方面介绍如何进行养生保健。
  • 剑道魔途

    剑道魔途

    人若拦我,我便杀了这人,山若挡我,我便碎了这山,天若阻我,我就逆了这天!强者之路,必伏尸百万,血染一生。辰烈手持魔剑傲视苍穹,俯视苍生,谁敢与我一战?
  • 哈佛教授给学生讲的200个心理健康故事

    哈佛教授给学生讲的200个心理健康故事

    给予心灵营养的成长箴言录,提升心理素质的智慧枕边书。200个心理健康故事,滋养学生的心田。品味百年哈佛的智慧甘泉,锻造和谐阳光的心理素质。